A high quality insulated bottle can keep your drinks cold or hot all day long. For two great brands to compare, check out the Takeya vs Hydro Flask bottles.
Insulated bottles can be quite handy, keeping your cold drinks from warming up on a hot day and retaining the heat of coffee or tea when the weather’s chilly.
But with so many different insulated thermos bottle brands to choose from, it’s hard to know which to buy.
Hydro Flask is one of the top models, but Takeya has many of the same features and comes with a lower price tag.
So, which is the best insulated water bottle? Check out our Takeya vs Hydro Flask review below to find out.
Takeya vs Hydro Flask: What to Look for in an Insulated Bottle
You may just need a small bottle for a short walk or one that can hold enough liquids to last the whole day. Thankfully, both models in our Takeya vs Hydro Flask comparison have a few options.
The Takeya thermo flask has 5 size options. These are the 14 oz, 18 oz, 24 oz, 32 oz, and 40 oz bottles in their Original collection. Their Actives collection also has a huge 64 oz bottle.
The Hydro Flask comes in similar sizes, including the 12 oz, 18 oz, 21 oz, 24 oz, 32 oz, 40 oz, and 64 oz. These come with either standard or wide-mouth lids, depending which one you buy.
Rather than comparing the weight of every size, we’ll just focus on the 18 oz bottles. The Takeya water bottle is only 0.8 lb, pretty light when empty, though it will weigh a bit more once you fill it up. The Hydro Flask thermos is a bit lighter at 0.7 lb.
Materials & Durability
The Takeya insulated flasks are made of food grade 18/8 stainless steel. They are BPA-free, with a sweat-free double-wall design. It has a powder coating on the outside of the bottle to give you an easy grip, but this coating also keeps the outside of the bottle comfortable to hold, even when it sits in the sun.
When comparing the Takeya vs Hydro Flask, you won’t find much difference in the materials. The Hydro Flask insulated water bottle also uses 18/8 Stainless steel, though Pro-Grade instead of food-grade.
These bottles are BPA-free, but are also Phthalate-free as well. There is also a proprietary powder coating, which gives you a sweat-free but tight grip on these durable water bottles.
Insulating performance is one of the most important features for bottles like these. The Takeya water bottles have that double-wall design, coupled with vacuum insulation to keep drinks cold or hot without a sweaty bottle. They boast ice cold drinks for up to 24 hours and piping hot ones for up to 12 hours.
Hydro Flask uses TempShield insulation, which has a similar double-wall vacuum insulation inside. These bottles also have the same claims as the Takeya bottles for both cold and hot drinks. This insulation even eliminates condensation on the outside of the bottle.
All the water bottle sizes from Takeya come in six colors, with the exception of the 14 oz, which only comes in 5 colors.
The Hydro Flask water bottles range from 3 to 11 colors, depending on which size you buy.
Takeya’s website states “Warranty: Awesome. Guaranteed.” They believe in their products enough to offer a limited lifetime warranty for their bottles, which keeps you safe from defects in materials and workmanship for the normal lifetime of these products. This warranty covers the bottle’s body, lid, cap, and handle. Normal wear and tear aren’t covered, of course.
The Hydro Flask water bottle warranty is similar, giving you a limited lifetime warranty against manufacturer defects for the life of the product. This warranty is for all their products. As Hydro Flask says, “We stand behind our products.”
Again, we’re going to compare the prices for only the 18 oz bottles. If you want a cheap hydro flask alternative, the Takeya bottles are a good option. The 18 oz costs only $24.99, which is $5.00 cheaper than the 18 oz insulated water bottle on the Hydro Flask site. Of course, you may find cheaper prices on other sites, so check your options before you buy.
As well as the great insulation and powder coating found on these two bottle brands, there are a few other features that make them worth the money.
The Takeya insulated thermos flask has no flavor transfer, even when switching beverages, even with just a quick rinse with water. It has a wide mouth to make it easy to add ice to your drink.
The Original Spout Lid is leak-proof, with a unique spout that lets you sip, chug, or pour as needed without removing it. There is hinge-lock to keep the cap from dropping onto your face while you tip it back and take a drink. And there is a wide loop handle that swings smoothly on a stainless steel pin when walking.
There are both standard and wide-mouth options in the Hydro Flask bottles, with the wide-mouth giving you a faster fill and more room for ice. There are also different lid types, including the Standard Mouth Insulated Sport Cap, The Standard Mouth Flex Cap, The Wide Mouth Flex Cap (with or without straw), and the Hydro Flip, depending on which bottle you buy.
Buying Guide: What to Look for in an Insulated Bottle
Size and Weight
Most insulated water bottles are quite light, making them easy to carry whether packing them in a bag or carrying them by hand during a hike. Of course, when you fill them up, this may add an extra pound or two, depending on how much they hold. But don’t worry about that, the more you drink, the lighter they’ll get.
As for the size, most brands have a few to choose from. This way, you can get the perfect one for a quick cup of morning coffee or a long day on the trail.
Materials & Durability
A good quality thermos flask needs to be made of quality materials, or it will be covered in dents and scratches after only a few days of use.
This is especially true if you plan on using your bottle out in the woods where it can be dropped on rocks or scraped with pointy tree branches.
That’s why most brands use stainless steel or other sturdy metals to make a durable insulated water bottle that lasts for years.
Decent materials for the lids are also important to make sure they don’t crack when bumped or when enduring any high temperature changes.
A good insulated water bottle will be able to retain the temperature of whatever it’s holding, otherwise, it can’t justifiably be called an insulated bottle. That’s why the best bottles, like the Takeya thermo flask vs the Hydro Flask, have added double wall vacuum insulation, which is the best type there is.
This type of insulation uses two walls, with a small space of evacuated air in the middle. This reduces heat transfer, so the outside air won’t affect the drinks inside, and the outside bottle won’t be too hot or cold to touch.
This keeps your drinks at the optimal temperature inside the bottle, no matter how long it takes you to finish it off.
If you want a cheap thermos flask to use as an everyday water bottle or just to use for those trips away from home, you can find one for a decently low price.
Some models go as low as $10. But you may be sacrificing a few features, such as the insulation. Cheaper bottles use cheaper materials, so the bottle may not do it job as well as higher quality models.
Hydro Flask bottles are a bit pricey but give you quality materials and insulation. But for a bottle like Hydro Flask, but cheaper, brands like Takeya are a great option to save a few bucks.
One neat feature to look for is a lack of flavor transfer. If you finish you’re coffee and fill your bottle with beer after a quick rinse, you don’t want that lingering coffee flavor to spoil the taste. Bottles like the Takeya have taken this into account, eliminating the taste transfer for drinks that taste like they’re supposed to.
You also want to look at the lid of the bottle. It should be made of durable plastic or rubber to insulate while resisting damage. You can choose wide mouth or standard mouth, with or without a straw, depending on your personal preference. And a handle makes it easy to carry by hand, plus gives you the option of attaching your bottle to a carabiner and hanging it from your belt or pack.
Bottom Line: Takeya vs Hydro Flask, Which is the Best?
There are so many great features of insulated bottles that it may be hard to choose the right one, especially with so many brands to choose from.
But we’ve taken some of the guesswork out for you, showing you the best and the worst in our Takeya vs Hydro Flask comparison.
Both brands offer quality bottles with great double-wall vacuum insulation that keep your drinks at the perfect temperature. But these two also have similar sizes, materials, coating, and they are both BPA-free.
This is especially true since it has that handy feature that promises no flavor transfer, which the Hydro Flask doesn’t seem to offer.